Two fires, one truck: Cole-Hamilton challenges Swinney on fire crew shortages

5 Nov 2026
Alex Cole-Hamilton MSP

Ahead of Bonfire Night, Scottish Liberal Democrat leader Alex Cole-Hamilton MSP challenged the First Minister over the extent to which fire crew shortages are leaving many larger fire stations unable to operate their second engines, despite the fact that these stations should have two fire engines ready to go at all times.

Several factors, including staffing shortages, can mean that stations are unable to dispatch a crew or vehicle to an emergency call.

Scottish Liberal Democrat freedom of information requests to Scottish Fire and Rescue have revealed that in the last financial year, the permanently crewed fire stations worst affected by the unavailability of a second engine were:

  1. Kilmarnock, unavailable 27.2% of the time
  2. Stirling, unavailable 25.7% of the time.
  3. North Anderson Drive in Aberdeen, unavailable 23% of the time.
  4. Mcdonald Road in Edinburgh, unavailable 22.9% of the time.
  5. Paisley, unavailable 22.3% of the time.
  6. Pollok in Glasgow, unavailable 21.8% of the time.
  7. Dunfermline, unavailable 21.7% of the time.
  8. Blackness Road in Dundee, unavailable 21% of the time.
  9. Coatbridge, unavailable 20.9% of the time.
  10. Sighthill in Edinburgh, unavailable 20.9% of the time.

At First Minister’s Questions, the Scottish Liberal Democrat leader also highlighted that there are at least 1,000 vacancies among on-call, firefighters in Scotland, which disproportionately affects rural fire services who rely on retained crews.

Speaking in the chamber, Alex Cole-Hamilton MSP said:

“Larger fire stations should have at least two engines ready to go at all times.

“But today, we are publishing new research. It shows just how often, in places like Kilmarnock, Stirling, Aberdeen, Glasgow and Edinburgh, that second fire engine cannot be operated, because there is nobody there to operate it.

“Can the First Minister see the basic arithmetical problem that could arise: two fires, one truck?”

Scottish Liberal Democrat MSP for Ross, Skye and Lochaber, Andrew Baxter, whose constituency was the site of this summer's Nethy Bridge wildfire, said:

“The SNP government is taking some pretty big gambles with lives and livelihoods.

“Even stations in the central belt, which are lucky enough to be permanently crewed, are finding themselves short staffed. Meanwhile, in the islands and rural north, many of our fire stations are stations in name only, because there is no one there to operate them. That inevitably means longer response times and greater risks.

“It’s time for ministers to step in and commission a probe into whether Scotland’s current defences are fit for purpose.

“No one will ever fault Scotland’s firefighters for effort or service. That needs to be matched by leadership from fire service bosses and the ministers who sit behind them.”

This website uses cookies

Please select the types of cookies you want to allow.